Sonith Manakkat

Trading, part 7 of 910 min read13 visuals

Risk management basics

Why the first question is how much could be lost, and how position size, stop limits, drawdown, diversification and pre-order checks work. General education only.

  • The first question is how much could be lost, not how much could be gained
  • A fall needs a bigger rise to recover, and a stop limit is not a promise
  • Risk checks belong before orders, like a gate

Share on LinkedIn

Share
Reading level

Most people start by asking what a position might gain. Risk management starts from the opposite end: what is the most this could cost, and could I live with that? This part explains the main ideas in plain language, each followed by an Expert view. All numbers are illustrative and nothing here is advice.

Start with the loss, not the gain

How muchcould belost?Is thatacceptable?Only then,how big?Decide
The order of questions, as a principle.
Expert viewWhy the loss comes first

A gain has no fixed limit in principle, but the possible loss can be known in advance for some products and can exceed the amount put in for others. Risk is usually described with a maximum loss (the worst case), an expected loss under assumptions, and a tail (rare, large events). Estimates rest on models, and models can be wrong, so the maximum loss is the most solid number to know.

Position sizing: how big is one position

  1. CapitalIllustrative: 10,000 units
  2. Risk fractionIllustrative: 1 percent, so 100 units
  3. Loss per unitIllustrative: 5 units if the plan fails
  4. Size100 divided by 5 gives 20 units
A fixed fraction of capital at risk, illustrative.
Expert viewSizing formulas in words

Fixed fractional: size equals capital times the risk fraction, divided by the loss per unit if the plan fails. Fixed amount: the same money at risk each time, regardless of capital. Volatility-scaled: size is inversely proportional to a measure of how much the price typically moves, so quieter things get larger positions and wilder things smaller ones. Kelly-style formulas relate size to an assumed edge and odds; they depend on inputs that cannot be known precisely and are very sensitive to errors, so practitioners often discuss using only a fraction of the result. These are descriptions of concepts, not recommendations.

Stop limits: an exit agreed in advance

What it is

  • A level agreed before the emotion starts
  • Removes in-the-moment second guessing

What it is not

  • A price jump (a gap) can skip over the level
  • Not a promise of the exit price (slippage)
A stop limit, and what it cannot do.
YouBrokerMarketStop, trigger 95Price gapsTrigger touchedBecomes marketFilled near 93Slippage 2123456
  1. You to Broker You place a stop order with a trigger level of 95.
  2. Market (to itself) The price jumps from above 95 to 93, with no trades in between.
  3. Market to Broker The trigger level has been passed.
  4. Broker (to itself) A stop order turns into a market order.
  5. Market to Broker (reply) The fill is the next price available, not 95.
  6. Broker to You (reply) The gap between trigger and fill is slippage.

Takeaway. A stop is a trigger, not a promised price, and a gap can skip the level.

A stop order when the price jumps. Illustrative numbers.
Expert viewGaps, slippage and stop types

A stop order becomes a market order when the trigger level is touched, so the fill can be well beyond the trigger when prices jump or liquidity is thin. A stop-limit order sets a worst acceptable price, but then may not fill at all. Neither can protect against a market that is closed overnight. The distance between the trigger and the actual fill is slippage, and it tends to be largest exactly when markets move fastest.

Daily loss limit: a circuit breaker

Losses add upA limit isreachedNew ordersstopA humanreviewsrepeat
A circuit breaker for the day.
daily loss limit of 300 units (illustrative)123
  1. First loss A third of the limit is used.
  2. Second loss Two thirds of the limit is used.
  3. Third loss The limit is reached, new orders stop and a person reviews.

Takeaway. A loss limit turns a vague worry into a number that ends the day when it is reached.

A daily loss limit being used up. Illustrative.

Drawdown: the fall from a peak

Fall from the peakRise needed to recover (illustrative)
10 percentabout 11 percent
20 percent25 percent
30 percentabout 43 percent
50 percent100 percent
80 percent400 percent
Expert viewDrawdown maths

If the fall is d (as a fraction), the rise r needed to recover satisfies (1 minus d) times (1 plus r) equals 1, so r equals d divided by (1 minus d). Maximum drawdown is the largest peak-to-trough fall in a period; drawdown duration is how long it takes to regain the peak, and can matter as much as depth. Consecutive percentage changes multiply, they do not add, which is why a 10 percent loss followed by a 10 percent gain does not return to the start.

Diversification, and where it stops helping

One basket

  • One bad event hits everything
  • Simple to follow

Several baskets

  • One bad event hurts only part
  • In stress, many things can fall together
Eggs and baskets.
Expert viewCorrelation in stress

Diversification works to the extent that the parts are not perfectly correlated. Correlation is measured from past data and is not constant: it often rises in market stress, so the diversification benefit measured in calm periods can shrink when it is most needed. Concentration risk is the opposite problem: one position, sector, counterparty or idea making up a large share of the total, so a single event has an outsized effect. Hidden concentration (different positions driven by the same underlying factor) is common.

Leverage multiplies risk

ExposureIllustrative: 10 times capitalCapitalThe amount actually put inResultSmall moves become big ones
Leverage stacks borrowed exposure on top of capital.

Why risk checks come before orders

An idea toactRisk checksGate:allowed?Order sent
The gate sits before the order.
Size limitnot above the agreed sizeExposure limittotal at risk stays inside a capDaily loss limitstop when reachedData sanitystale or odd values are refused
Typical pre-order checks, as layers of a gate.
  1. 1Is the size above the agreed size?Yes Stopped at the size limit.No keep going
  2. 2Would total exposure pass its cap?Yes Stopped at the exposure limit.No keep going
  3. 3Is the daily loss limit already reached?Yes Stopped, and no new orders are allowed that day.No keep going
  4. 4Is the data stale or odd?Yes Stopped, because a wrong number is refused.No keep going
  5. 5OtherwiseEvery check says yes, so the order may be sent.

Takeaway. The order cannot exist until every check says yes.

The gate before an order. Any check that says no stops the order.
Expert viewPre-trade versus post-trade checks

Pre-trade checks are deterministic tests applied to a proposed order (size, price band, limits, duplicates) and can reject it. Post-trade checks monitor what actually happened (positions, exposure, unexpected fills) and raise alarms or trigger reductions. Both are needed: pre-trade stops known problems, post-trade catches the surprises the first set did not foresee.

Operational risks and a kill switch

  • OutagesA system or connection fails at a bad moment
  • Bad dataA wrong or stale number drives a decision
  • Fat-finger errorsA typo makes an order far too large
  • Duplicate ordersA retry sends the same order twice
Risks that are not about price.
Expert viewRisk of ruin intuition

Risk of ruin is the chance that losses reach a level from which recovery is practically impossible. Intuitively it grows with larger position sizes, with higher variability of outcomes, and with a lower chance of favourable outcomes; it falls when each position is small relative to capital. It is a modelling concept: real markets violate the neat assumptions behind simple formulas, so treat any quoted figure as rough.

The first question is how much could be lost, not how much could be gained.

Frequently asked questions

Does a stop limit cap the loss?

Not strictly. Gaps and slippage mean the exit can be at a worse price than the level.

Why does recovery need a bigger percentage than the fall?

Because the percentage is applied to a smaller amount after the fall.

Does diversification remove risk?

No. It can reduce some kinds of risk, but things can move together in stress.

Is a small risk fraction a recommendation?

No. The numbers here are illustrative to show the arithmetic.

Back to all articles